Background
Earlier this year, former England cricketer Paul Collingwood became the latest high-profile individual to have made an appearance in the UK tax courts.
Collingwood was the sole shareholder of P D C Rights Limited, a UK incorporated company to which he had purported to assign his intellectual property rights, and any analogous intangible rights.
It is far from uncommon for high-profile sportspeople to use similar vehicles, often broadly referred to as ‘image rights companies. These are companies which hold and exploit the image rights of the relevant sportsperson.
A typical UK ‘image rights company’ (“IRC”) arrangement would involve the sportsperson’s employer (or others) making a payment to the IRC in return for the ability to use the individual’s image for such as its own promotional purposes and use on merchandise.
The potential tax benefits of an IRC arrangement rather than paying the sportsperson individually are broadly similar to a contractor v employee arrangement: 1) corporation tax rates are lower than income tax rates, 2) where relevant, there is no employer or employee’s national insurance arising on the payment from the engaging party to an IRC, 3) the ability for the IRC to deduct business expenses against the income received and also 4) the flexibility on the timing of cash extraction. This last point can be particularly valuable for sportspeople who might subsequently leave the UK, become UK non-resident, and may liquidate the IRC without being subject to UK capital gains tax.
What this case concerned
The FTT heard an appeal from the taxpayer against closure notices issued by HMRC which assessed total income taxof £196,187 (arising across four tax years) on the taxpayer on the basis that sponsorship payments from three different parties were assessable on him personally, rather than on P D C Rights Limited.
The sponsors made payments in return for the taxpayer wearing certain equipment, attending events, and reaching certain sporting milestones.
HMRC had opened an earlier enquiry into sponsorship payments from one of the parties during 2008 and closed it in 2009 without adjustment.
The specific appealed issues were as follows:
In early 2005, and so prior to entering into the sponsorship agreements, the taxpayer and P D C Rights Limited had entered into an agreement for the assignment of intellectual property rights.
Although each of the relevant sponsorship agreements are dated post the formation of P D C Rights Limited, the taxpayer signed each of these personally, not as a company representative.
In certain instances, the taxpayer’s agency company was a party to the contract however in one instance it was expressly clear that the agent was merely responsible for invoicing and collecting amounts.
The taxpayer could not assign certain sponsorship contracts without the written agreement of the contracting parties, and no such evidence was produced.
HMRC submitted that as the taxpayer is the person receiving or entitled to the profits from the payments, he is liable to tax pursuant to s8 and s5 ITTOIA 2005 or s687 ITTOIA 2005.
The taxpayer’s Counsel argued that the sponsorship payments were for the company’s services and that the parties to the contract are not relevant.
Regarding the legitimate expectation argument – HMRC submitted that the FTT does not have authority to consider such arguments, whereas counsel for the taxpayer argued that HMRC cannot reconsider matters which are factually and legally the same as that submitted in respect of an earlier tax year and have not been amended by HMRC in the course of an enquiry.
The tribunal’s decision
Upon considering the relevant agreements, the fact that taxpayer was a contracting party and the lack of valid assignment of the sponsorship agreements from the taxpayer to P D C Rights Limited were key to the FTT finding that there was no evidence that the taxpayer had no legal right to benefit from the sponsorship agreements.
On the point of legitimate expectation, for this to arise there must be a clear, unambiguous promise or representation on which the taxpayer has relied. This was not evident in the closure notice from the earlier enquiry and the FTT agreed that such public law arguments were not within its jurisdiction.
Both appeals were dismissed.
Why is this relevant?
The readership of this publication is undoubtedly aware of the need for underlying contracts to robustly set out (among other things) the contracting parties, their roles, rights, and obligations.
The contractual arrangements will often provide the start and end point in any analysis and form an integral part of our work. It is best practice for the contractual arrangements to reflect the preceding tax advice fully and accurately as well as reflect the economic and commercial realities.
Secondly, and however much our clients may want it to be true, HMRC’s silence does not equal acceptance. The established route to seeking HMRC’s view on the tax treatment of a transaction is to engage directly via statutory and non-statutory clearances.
Disclaimer - Accurate at time of publication